Gwyn Roberts
Some notes and observations on Scott Reiss’s recorder technique
Scott was an exceptionally gifted musician. As a recorder player, he joined his eloquent flair for expressive delivery and phrasing with the sort of virtuosic technique on his instrument that allowed him to deliver whatever gesture, flourish or emotional knock-out punch was in his mind at the time.
But, as a recorder player, he faced the anomaly that he was playing an instrument with hundreds of years of history but no clear technical tradition. Starting in the baroque era, pedagogues for other instruments wrote treatises that addressed technical questions with increasing specificity — François Couperin for harpsichord, Leopold Mozart for violin, Marin Marais for the gamba — but no such work was ever written about the recorder, which was primarily a doubling instrument for oboists at the time. Recorder players got some fingering charts, a bunch of articulation symbols and the same sort of instruction on how to improvise ornamentation that was provided to other instrumentalists, but nothing about basics like breathing, blowing, holding the instrument or where, exactly, to put your tongue when executing those articulation syllables. And the recorder revival of the mid-20th century only contributed to the technical entropy, with many professionals cobbling their technique together from advice developed for modern flute, oboe and voice. Not ideal.
Scott approached the problem with resourcefulness and creativity. He took the few crumbs left to us from those historical treatises and developed his own method. His articles about articulation published in the American Recorder Magazine are highly analytical, describing in great detail what he observed inside his own mouth while he played. And his approach to holding and fingering the instrument was likewise built on a few clues left in historical fingering charts. But much of the details of what he did remains a mystery to me and to those students of his with whom I have spoken.
I played alongside Scott only once in concert and a few times in rehearsal, as he and I explored the possibility of playing a duo recital together in the months before he died. What I noticed were two brilliant innovations, both of which I have incorporated into my own playing and teaching.
One was his translation of the most common compound articulation syllables in historical treatises, which depend on linguistic analogies that worked for speakers of 18th century French, German or Italian, into something that works for speakers of modern American English. Instead of the usual Tu Ru Du Ru or Ti Ri Di Ri, which rely on deft use of the flipped R to work, Scott referred to the double-sided tongue action that happens when you pronounce teeter totter — the playground aparatus — to produce the same effect easily. He morphed teeter totter into teeder deeder, regularizing the vowels to make a combination that can be repeated quickly and easily with just the tip of the tongue. He never explained this to me. He just pointed to a passage in a duet we were working on and said out loud the syllables he was planning to use to play it.
Similarly, Scott took a cue from historical fingering charts for both recorder and flute that used extra fingers to stabilize the instrument and turned it into a system. When playing a difficult passage that involved the notes surrounding the transition from the first to the second octave of the recorder, he figured out which other fingers he could leave on their holes that wouldn’t affect pitch and used them to secure the instrument while he played blazingly fast. Again, he never told me about this, but I observed it in his hands at the time and see it clearly when watching his videos now.
