Consorting With Fantasy At the Folger
The Washington Post
Tim Page
February 27, 1996
Washington, D.C.
Concert Review
Consorting with fantasy at the Folger, variations on varied themes.
On a soft, foggy evening, an Anglophile wandering the streets of Capitol Hill may briefly imagine himself in London. One way to prolong and reinforce this pleasant fantasy is to find one’s way to the multi-tiered, Tudor-style theater at the Folger Shakespeare Library.
And indeed, fantasy was the order of the evening on Friday night, when Scott Reiss, one of the three founding members of the Folger Consort (the Library’s ensemble-in-residence) presented a program called “Fantasia,” with two colleagues, Tina Chancey and Grant Herreid.
It was in every way a delightful concert, exploring many kinds of music in a manner that was wide-ranging but never scattered, informative but never didactic. As Reiss put it in his program notes, “Fantasia refers to an instrumental piece improvised or written for one or more instruments, usually without fixed formal constraints. Normally a fantasia would employ different kinds of variation on a theme, or imitation, the theme of one voice being echoed in others, although not carried out to formal extremes as in a baroque fugue.”
And so we heard “fantasias” for solo recorder, for seven-string viola da gamba, for lute, for guitar, for combinations of all these instruments and more. The composers were a diverse bunch, too; the list included Orlando Gibbons, Josquin Desprez, Georg Philipp Telemann and Henry Purcell (a gently mournful and deeply affecting trio for three recorders—how quickly one recognizes this composer’s patrician voice).
The three musicians conjured up an extraordinary array of sounds—from the sweet, reedy tone of Reiss’s recorder (delicate, but a delicacy that carried) through the near barn-dance exuberance of some duets for viol and lute. At times one was reminded of a sort of jam session—the kind found on some of those early San Francisco rock albums by groups like Country Joe and the Fish or Quicksilver Messenger Service—and I mean that as a compliment. Here, scholarship and formal understanding were leavened with an easy, appreciative spontaneity that is too often missing from performances of medieval, baroque and Renaissance music.
Some readers may remember a controversy that followed the Folger Consort’s January program. On that concert, a piece titled “A que do bon rey Davi,” with flagrantly antisemitic lyrics, was performed and the Anti-Defamation League wrote a letter of complaint.
A note in the program on Friday acknowledged that the Folger Consort “had a profound responsibility to read or perform the material so that the student or the listener is instructed about past attitudes and atrocities—that they may never again be repeated.”
“We did not meet this responsibility by adequately addressing the deep religious bigotry against Jews that existed in medieval Spain and discussing in the program notes how those attitudes still threaten many Jews today,” the note continued. “We are deeply sorry that we offended some of you and we intend to do a better job of addressing those concerns in the future.”
In a statement, David C. Friedman, director of the ADL’s Washington regional office, called the Consort’s apology “forceful and compassionate.” “It recognizes the Consort’s responsibilities to its audience and to the community at large,” he Friedman. “Antisemitic and racist attitudes from the past must be presented with sensitivity to the feelings of a contemporary audience and must be handled with an awareness that in 1996 religious hatred is not a thing of the past.”
